"Setting Down the Stone" - Rev Adam Slate

Introduction

My grandmother died in 2002. Jewish law dictates that a funeral should happen quickly so as not to dishonour the dead, and so my aunt planned the funeral to happen within 48 hours. My dad was travelling in Alaska when it happened, way too far away to get home in time. He loved my grandmother dearly; he was off on Mondays and visited her most weeks. He asked my aunt to delay the funeral, which she declined to do because she felt it was appropriate to be strict with Jewish custom. She did this from a place of love she also had for my grandmother and my grandmother’s adherence to her Jewish faith.

That conflict ended my dad’s relationship with my aunt. They both lived another twenty years or so, and as far as I know, they never talked again. So they lost both a parent and a sibling.

The decision to forgive or not to forgive is tied to so many things. The degree of anger we feel. The approach the person who has hurt us takes toward reconciliation. The trust that we have built up. And the trauma that may be at the heart of the injury we have suffered.

Modern conventional wisdom tells us to forgive, or to ‘forgive and forget.’ The Christianity that underpins much of Western culture sees forgiveness as a commandment. These easy approaches to forgiveness sidestep much of the complexity around it and often do not seem like satisfying guidance for how we might approach forgiveness.

The question of forgiveness touches us at a societal level as well as a personal level. Issues such as reparations for slavery, recognition of stolen land, and the return of artefacts from museums to the cultures who created them all require people to wrestle with whether or how to extend forgiveness.

Forgiveness Is Different from Repair

But before we say more about forgiveness, I want to make a distinction between forgiveness and relationship repair. It’s easy to think that they go together, but I believe the key to doing either of them well is to keep them a bit separate.

Almost a thousand years ago, a 12th century Jewish philosopher named Maimonides unpacked a rigorous and thoughtful process for relationship repair. Repair and repentance are important in Jewish culture, particularly during the month leading up to Rosh Hashanah—the Jewish New Year—and during the ten days between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, the Day for Atonement. In Jewish culture, atoning and making amends doesn’t just take place on one day of fasting on Yom Kippur. Yom Kippur is the culmination of more than a month of self-reflection.

A few years ago, a rabbi named Danya Ruttenberg wrote a book called On Repentance and Repair highlighting Maimonides’ approach to repair and reconciliation. But the wisdom behind this work was not developed by Maimonides; it aligns with writings from other traditions about repair, repentance, and reconciliation that go back much earlier.

Maimonides breaks this work of repair into five steps: naming and owning harm; making amends for the harm we have caused; changing our behaviour; apologising; and allowing ourselves to be transformed.

Notice that this process does not talk at all about forgiveness. It only requires us to acknowledge how we have caused harm, and work to make things right. The assumption here is that repair and forgiveness are separate paths. The person we have wronged is not required to forgive us, and our path to repair does not require that we be forgiven. In fact, to do reconciliation work well, we may need to let go of the idea of being forgiven.

Beyond our individual relationships, we have seen this type of repair at the societal level in places like Rwanda and South Africa that have lived through genocide and apartheid. Reconciliation processes, although flawed and subject to criticism—for example, South Africa offered conditional amnesty for some who confessed to politically-motivated crimes—have focused on truth-telling and restorative justice as a way of finding a path forward after nearly impossible circumstances.

Like I said earlier, our culture puts a lot of emphasis on forgiveness. For the person who has suffered harm, we can be encouraged to ‘let go of grudges and move on.’ Or we might want to avoid discomfort by smoothing over conflicts quickly. This kind of fast forgiveness often derails true repentance work.

And worse, we can do real harm to ourselves if we offer forgiveness while there’s still work going on within ourselves. We may be wrestling with deep hurt or trauma. We may have reasons why we don’t feel we can offer forgiveness. We may have our own work to do, and that’s okay; and it can happen on our own timeframe.

Freeing Ourselves through Radical Self-Compassion

Tara Brach is a psychologist, author, and teacher of mindfulness, emotional healing, and Buddhist meditation. In her book Radical Compassion, she describes two phases of forgiveness. The first requires us to ‘heal the woundedness beneath [the anger or] blame’ that we may be feeling.[1] It is an inward-facing process of looking at what is happening inside ourselves as a result of the harm we have suffered, and nurturing what we need to heal that wounded part of us. This step is an act of self-compassion.

Once we have tended to our own hurt, trauma, and emotional needs, we can work on bringing what she calls ‘compassionate attention’ to the person or people we are working to forgive.[2] The meditation that Sue led earlier, although it was entitled ‘A Blessing for the One I Cannot Forgive,’ is actually an example of bringing this kind of compassionate attention to someone who has hurt us, which can be part of forgiveness.[3]

Notice I say that this is a step we take towards a person or people we are working to forgive. We may not be at this point. We may not be working to forgive someone. In that case, our entire work might be self-compassion to examine and work toward healing our own wounds.

Looking at Dr Brach’s approach to forgiveness begs the question: Who does forgiveness free? When we are taught about forgiveness as children, most of us are taught that it is a gift, a kindness we extend to others, but are we ourselves not freed as much by the act of forgiving as those we forgive?

Holding onto anger, hurt, or blame can sit like a weight tied around us. We may feel like we cannot forgive until we get past it. Our healing process, our work, is about approaching that hurt or anger with curiosity, to find the wound that lies beneath it, and confront it through self-care and self-compassion, possibly with the help of a professional. The reward that comes from working towards forgiveness is often being able to find healing for that wounded place so we no longer feel its pull on us, and finally being able to set down the heavy stone of anger and blame that we have been carrying.

If you would like, take a moment to picture this: Someone’s actions have left you angry or hurt. It does not have to be a real memory. You feel its sting. You feel its weight on your heart. And then one day—as a result of self-reflection, self-care, maybe journaling, or therapy… and time—you feel that the weight has lessened and you are coming out the other side.

Maybe this is what forgiveness feels like, whether you put that word to it or not. Maybe forgiveness is mostly about freeing ourselves.

It’s what the first partner in the story we heard earlier showed us. Loving meant letting go rather than holding onto anger or blame. Setting down the stone.

It’s what my father and my aunt could not do. They lived with their anger, and they carried that weight for the rest of their lives. That anger came from real hurt, and we can understand it. But it cost them, and it cost their families.

It’s possible to find healing, so that we can set down our stone.

‘Impossible’ Forgiveness

This coming Thursday up near Finsbury Park at St Mellitus church there’s an event called ‘Listening from the Heart’ organised by a group called The Parents Circle - Family Forum. The only way to join The Parents Circle is to be an Israeli or Palestinian parent who has lost a child to violence. Members share their personal stories with each other, and work together toward dialogue, peace, reconciliation, and preventing future bereavement.

Anyone from a Jewish or Palestinian family, or who has Jewish or Palestinian friends, knows how complex emotions can be around this conflict, and yet these parents have found a way to enter into relationship with each other.

Similarly, in rare cases, people have forgiven—and in some cases forged friendships with—those who have committed violence against parents, spouses, or children, deciding that forgiveness is preferable to living with the hatred they were holding. A Dutch author, Maurits Chabot, just published a book called The Divide, documenting cases of people forgiving the seemingly unforgivable in order to learn what motivated them.

This is a complicated topic, and I want to name that some of us may have experienced this kind of violence in our own families. Forgiveness and the path to healing is always a personal choice. You may not want forgiveness on the table right now, or ever. It’s always your choice.

Conclusion

In his foreword to the 25th anniversary edition of the book The Alchemist, the author Paulo Coelho wrote about the ability for humans to find places of understanding. ‘This continues to give me hope,’ he said. ‘It is always within my power to build a bridge. There is always a chance for reconciliation, a chance that one day [my neighbour] and I will sit around a table together and put an end to our history of clashes. And on this day, he will tell me his story and I will tell him mine.’

Can we get to that place? Of healing, of bridge building? Can we set down the stone? Maybe we can’t, or are not ready today, and that’s not a failure. Yet I hope that when the time is right, when we do, if we do, we will come to know the gifts that can await us on the other side.

Blessed be.

Notes:
[
1] Tara Brach, ‘Radical Compassion,’ 161.
[2] Tara Brach, ‘Radical Compassion,’ 161.
[3] Rumni Saha, ‘A Blessing for the One I Cannot Forgive,’ Unitarian Universalist Association, https://www.uua.org/worship/words/blessing/blessing-one-i-cannot-forgive.